Genuine Disagreement
1 fill-in slot · from The AI Prompt Handbook for Claude
Your details
0/1 filledGenuine Disagreement
I believe [your belief/plan/conclusion]. I want you to genuinely engage with this—not just validate me: 1. Where do you think I might be wrong? 2. What am I probably not considering? 3. What would a thoughtful critic say? 4. What assumptions am I making that deserve scrutiny? 5. If this fails, what's the most likely reason? Then: - If you actually agree with me, say so and explain why - If you have reservations, share them directly - If you think I'm making a mistake, tell me I value honesty over comfort. Polite agreement isn't helpful.
Highlighted [slots] are still empty. Downloads are plain .txt — paste into any AI assistant.