Steelman and Strawman

Before I form my opinion on [topic], help me understand all sides:

THE POSITION: [Statement or argument]

PROVIDE:

STEELMAN (strongest possible version):
- Present the most compelling version of this argument
- Use the best evidence and reasoning available
- Assume good faith and intelligence in proponents

STRAWMAN (common weak version):
- Show how this argument is often poorly made
- Identify weak evidence commonly used
- Explain why these versions fail

GENUINE COUNTERARGUMENTS:
- Present the strongest objections to the steelman
- These should be real challenges, not easy dismissals

SYNTHESIS:
- What's the kernel of truth in this position?
- Where does it genuinely fail?
- What's a more nuanced view?